Poll: Favourite Decade?

I was looking around the Blogger settings the other day when I noticed that I could set-up a quick ad-hoc poll here on the site without much effort. In light of a recent topic discussed on CBC Radio3, I've put up a poll question for the month of February: if you could only listen to music from a single decade, what would it be? What is your favourite decade of music?

Now, as we found out during the R3 broadcast, the early favourites seem to be the 1970s and the 2000s, but you have to realize what you're giving up to choose any single decade. The Beatles recorded 99% of their material in the 1960s... Pink Floyd recorded (arguably) their best stuff during the 1970s... The Smiths put out all their material in the 1980s... so, as you can see, it might not be as much about what you like to listen to as it is what you couldn't live without hearing again. And, for those great artists or bands who have recorded over the span of multiple decades (e.g., Bob Dylan, The Rolling Stones) make this sort of choice even harder!

So, if you've got a second, make a selection over there on the right (below the list of 'genres') and come back at the end of the month (if not sooner) and see how the results are shaping up!

Collective Soul - Hints, Allegations and Things Left Unsaid

This is the sound of a band trying to find their sound. This album has everything on it: (sampled?) hand claps, organ, symphonic instrumental interlude, faux-punk, acoustic track, and a few radio-friendly generic rock songs just for good measure. Oddly enough, despite all this effort, I don't think it sounds a thing like their follow-up album (although, that'll be another review, for another day).

But, before I go running off to the next album, let's have a bit of a look at this, the debut release from Collective Soul. There were, as I remember it, two "big" singles from this album: Shine and Breathe. Nearly twenty years later, the first song doesn't hold up as well as the other one, although I still take notice of the 'extended' solo included on the album that was always cut-out for radio play. Generally speaking, because of the constant mix of sounds and styles on the album, it feels very choppy as you listen through it.

According to Wikipedia, this album was actually a set of demos that the record label rushed into production to capitalize on the band's sound at the time, which would seem to make some sense given the varied nature of the songs. Whatever the case, listening to the album now, it sounds like very generic mainstream rock with a few, often too short, guitar solos thrown in for good measure.

As of today, the band is still touring and has released eleven albums in total (nine studio albums, one live album and a greatest hits package); their most recent release is their second(?) self-titled album.

Recommended track(s):	Love Lifted Me; Breathe
Worth another listen?	No.
Overall rating:	Two Stars

Brad Paisley - 5th Gear

I hate to say it, but I think my love for this album has waned over the years. Brad Paisley can still play like crazy and his lyrics are spot-on, clever, touching... but while the highlights are still quite good here, the lowlights don't seem to hold up as well.

As I'd written previously on my other blog, having seen Brad in concert was quite something... but it felt more like a pop music concert -- pre-rehearsed, filled with special effects and timed music videos on large screens, etc. -- than what I expected a country show to be.

Lyrically, songs like Ticks and Online are gold. They're funny, they flow well and tell great stories. These are songs that you can listen to a few times before you get all the little jokes tucked away in there. On top of that, however, are some good guitar licks and general production. Better Than This is another example of this that makes the latter half of the album for me.

My copy of the album has a few seemingly extra tracks at the end of it, some quasi-comedy outakes or something. I think the album would be a tiny bit better if it wrapped up after the first twelve songs; at 51 minutes it still makes for an average length album that people wouldn't complain about... but this is a pretty small complaint about the disc (and, again, this could be some sort of special edition or Canadian release of the disc, although I don't see anything on the disc that would indicate as much).

So, in short, the good songs are very good and certainly worth a listen; but I think the album does have a bit of filler that, after a few years, doesn't seem to hold up as well as it did initially.

Recommended track(s):	Ticks; Online; I'm Still a Guy
Worth another listen?	Yes!
Overall rating:	Three Stars